What’s more important–a Confession or a Conviction?

Anon alerted to me a news story about Iris L. Brown–a woman who was kidnapped, strangled and dumped along Interstate 89 in 1976. For 32 years, her family didn’t know what happened to her until a dying man in a Butner, NC, federal prison was offered immunity in return for the details of her death.

William Posey was sentenced to life in prison in 1980 for kidnapping her but never owned up to the murder. Cold case investigators and Ms. Brown’s family figured it was more important to find out what happened to her than getting a conviction for her murder. Their gamble paid off. They can at least put to rest all those questions in their mind. And since Posey is already serving a life sentence for another murder and is terminally ill, there didn’t seem to be any advantage to trying to bring him to trial for Iris Brown’s murder.

I’m curious to find out what you readers think about trading off immunity for a confession. At what point, if any, would you put that offer on the table if one of your family members were killed and you had a suspect for the murder?

Here’s the link to the rest of the newspaper article:



Maritime Missy


Leave a Reply